Book Review: Second Chance Summer by Morgan Matson

25 May

Book cover for Second Chance Summer by Morgan MatsonTitle: Second Chance Summer

Author: Morgan Matson

Genre: Contemporary YA

Publisher: Simon & Schuster Children’s

Release date: May 8, 2012

Challenge: Completely Contemporary Challenge

Source: Bought

Summary: Taylor’s family might not be the closest-knit – everyone is a little too busy and overscheduled – but for the most part, they get along fine. Then they get news that changes everything: Her father has pancreatic cancer, and it’s stage four – meaning that there is basically nothing to be done. Her parents decide that the family will spend his last months together at their old summerhouse in the Pocono Mountains.

Crammed into a place much smaller and more rustic than they are used to, they begin to get to know each other again. And Taylor discovers that the people she thought she had left behind haven’t actually gone anywhere. Her former summer best friend is suddenly around, as is her first boyfriend. . . and he’s much cuter at seventeen than he was at twelve.

As the summer progresses, the Edwards become more of a family, and closer than they’ve ever been before. But all of them very aware that they’re battling a ticking clock. Sometimes, though, there is just enough time to get a second chance – with family, with friends, and with love.

So quick story: Before I started reading SECOND CHANCE SUMMER by Morgan Matson, I saw that the uber-fabulous Tara from Hobbitses had read and reviewed it already. OF COURSE, because her reviews are wonderful, I checked it out. I can’t say I didn’t shout at my web browser, thinking that something was wrong with the Internet. Because guys, her review of SECOND CHANCE SUMMER is four words long. I was worried, I was anxious, and I was EXCITED to get reading. And now that I’ve finished reading it myself, I totally get it. I totally understand how you have all these feelings that don’t really have words, and that this book leaves you so emotional that you can’t think of how you might go about gathering your thoughts. (OBVIOUSLY, since I keep talking, I’m not having this problem to the extreme that I first believed.) SECOND CHANCE SUMMER is not really about the romance, not in the way Morgan Matson‘s debut, AMY & ROGER’S EPIC DETOUR was, although the relationship between Taylor and Henry is sweet and solid and I LOVED IT. No, this is a book about a daughter, first and foremost, and how she comes to appreciate and understand how much she loves her father . GUYS, I WELLED UP JUST WRITING THAT SENTENCE.

SECOND CHANCE SUMMER is already one of my favorite books of the year. BOOM. Truth bomb. Morgan Matson‘s sophomore book is basically amazing. AMY & ROGER’S EPIC DETOUR is one of my FAVORITE contemporary YAs, and if you’ve been around the blog before, the chances that you’ve seen me bring it up are high. I’ve loved Morgan Matson since, and knew without question that I would be anticipating SECOND CHANCE SUMMER. What I didn’t know, didn’t realize, is how different in tone the two books would be. I didn’t cry when I read about Amy and Roger and their KILLER road trip romance. But I found myself welling up all over the place while I was reading SECOND CHANCE SUMMER. There was such a sense of bittersweetness about it that just touched me. 

See, Taylor’s dad is sick, you guys. Very, very sick. Everyone in Taylor’s family knows that their time together is dwindling, which is why they all go to the Poconos for the summer, one last time together. They haven’t been back there in five years, thankfully for Taylor because she basically left a huge, dramatic pile of you-know-what there before she bolted liked a startled pony from the dramz. So the resolution of those issues hangs over the story in SECOND CHANCE SUMMER as well. But as well done as that all was (and it WAS AWESOME), it wasn’t what resonated with me the most. It wasn’t what made me cry. It wasn’t the part that I’m still–a week later–having a hard time thinking about without having FEELINGS. Because basically, Taylor and her family are slowly watching their father and husband die. And Morgan Matson makes that both sad and special at the same time. 

Because as incredibly well-drawn all of the characters are in SECOND CHANCE SUMMER, I had a particular soft spot for Taylor’s dad, Rob. Somehow, in my mind, he reminded me of my own dad, and I saw some similarities between our relationship and it just KILLED ME, y’all. It was just so…sad. But SECOND CHANCE SUMMER also had its share of sweet things, too. Sweet, special moments between Taylor and her dad, just the two of them, that REALLY got to me. So even when things take exactly the turn that I knew they would, I was both devastated and a little glad for Taylor, because she had those moments.

I know that I said this book wasn’t so much about the romance, but don’t get all frowny-face on me. It’s there. (THANKFULLY. I can’t even DEAL with how heartbroken I would have been without a little rekindled childhood romance to lighten things up a bit.) Henry is adorable and quiet and supportive and also WORKS IN A BAKERY and BRINGS TAYLOR BAKED GOODS. I mean, honestly. There was one scene where Taylor–who was great, by the way. Maybe a little standoffish, even as a character, but VERY empathetic, I thought–is helping him frost cupcakes (ALAS, not a euphemism) and she keeps sneaking little tastes. I was like, “PSH. I’d have that WHOLE THING polished off ASAP.” But their relationship takes time and hard work and is not the focus of SECOND CHANCE SUMMER. Which was actually pretty nice. It was perfect that way, to me. Because it let the spotlight shine on Taylor and her dad, and Henry was left to be an ACE boyfriend, a job he did well. 

Guys, I’ve been welling up a little bit while writing this review, so before I LOSE IT, let me wrap things up. SECOND CHANCE SUMMER by Morgan Matson was amazing. It was heartfelt and lovely and sad. I couldn’t put it down, and I didn’t want it to end, because I knew what would be coming when it did. I wanted the summer to just keep going forever so that Taylor and her family could always have this time together. BAH! THE SADZ! Morgan Matson was officially on my “must read” list BEFORE I read SECOND CHANCE SUMMER, and she’s only solidified her spot with this one, guys. If you don’t read many contemporaries, please check this one out (and AMY & ROGER’S EPIC DETOUR, too, while you’re at it). It’s wonderful. 


12 Responses to “Book Review: Second Chance Summer by Morgan Matson”

  1. Shanyn (@shanynlee) May 25, 2012 at 12:08 am #


  2. Tara @ Hobbitsies May 25, 2012 at 7:29 am #

    I love you and your talkative reviews. LOVE IT. “Morgan Matson makes that both sad and special at the same time.” SO TRUE.

  3. April C (@booksandwine) May 25, 2012 at 2:41 pm #

    You know I am going to read this and love the crap out of it. I keep waiting though to see if they make an audio of Second Chance Summer, cuz that’s how I read Amy And Roger, and I kind of want to keep that tradition up.

  4. Heidi May 25, 2012 at 10:23 pm #

    Oh God. This is clearly that type of book that I really want to read but am completely afraid to read because it will make me FEEL ALL THE THINGS. Seriously. More so even than like TFioS, because I am SUCH a daddy’s girl, and I swear to God I am tearing up here and now even thinking about the prospect of my father getting sick (and he is FINE).

  5. Hannah May 28, 2012 at 9:43 pm #

    Okay, so I rarely (if ever) cry when I’m reading a book. I promise I’m not heartless – I just don’t cry a lot & it takes a lot for a book to evoke tears. Anywaysss… so I read this because Magan at Rather Be Reading wrote an AMAZING review & convinced me that I needed to buy it right away. So I did. And read it immediately, even though I have books that I’ve owned for months and still haven’t read. And I confidently told Magan I wouldn’t cry. And then I did. A lot. The silent cry. I still haven’t written down my thoughts on the book because it just makes me feel a little weepy thinking about it. So, basically, I love your rambling thoughts on it because I think my review will be a little like this when I finally get around to it.

  6. megtao May 31, 2012 at 4:38 pm #

    I really want to read this now because you’ve given it such a glowing review, but I also really can’t deal with any more sad books since TFIOS…

  7. Stephanie @ Read in a Single Sitting May 31, 2012 at 8:34 pm #

    I had chills reading this one. I thought that Taylor’s “secret” was a little bit underwhelming, but the father-daughter element brought tears to my eyes. That last fifty pages or so–oh my goodness.

    • trippingbooks May 31, 2012 at 9:23 pm #

      I totally agree about the secret. In fact, I found myself HOPING that it would be something MAJOR because I couldn’t think of what a 12-year-old could have done that would have caused her friends to hate her guts 5 years later. But YES to the father-daughter aspect. I LOVED it.


  1. Top Ten Tuesday (41) « Tripping Over Books - August 21, 2012

    […] as a main plot device a dying character, this time it’s Taylor’s father, Rob. Guys, THIS BOOK. What an intense, special read. It’s sad all the time, but it has these little bright spots […]

  2. Top Ten Tuesday (44) « Tripping Over Books - September 11, 2012

    […] So many things to think about in Harry Potter world. I think that these books, though, are a really great encapsulation of what is so great about children’s literature, and how the best of it doesn’t presume that kids are incapable of doing great things. Of being smart and thoughtful and brave. Second Chance Summer by Morgan Matson […]

  3. Top Ten Tuesday (56) « - December 18, 2012

    […] I remember my own feelings while reading it and, remembering them, there’s no way I can leave SECOND CHANCE SUMMER off this list. Thankfully, my own father is alive and well, but there was something so similar in […]

  4. Peace Out, 2012: End of Year Book Survey « - December 28, 2012

    […] Contemporary: Second Chance Summer by Morgan Matson, Such A Rush by Jennifer Echols, The Statistical Probability of Love at First Sight by Jennifer E. Smith, Graffiti Moon by Cath Crowley (I will stop now. Clearly, 2012 was the Year of the Amazing Contemp) […]

Tell me what's up!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: